Satoshi nakamoto is he still alive bitcoin consolidating inputs

Self-Proclaimed Satoshi Nakamoto, Craig Wright, Replies to CFTC Request for Input (RFI)

You can unsubscribe at any time. The problem was, each how to get listed on binance reddit localbitcoin required special support code and data fields whether it was used or not, and only covered one special case at a time. Absolute no to any BitcoinSV. This will never happen. There is currently no publicly available cryptographic proof that anyone in particular is Bitcoin's creator. Same amount of money, just different convention for where the ","'s and ". Nonetheless, he did not withdraw the motion. The intention was rapid growth and appreciation in value. So what we are focusing on here is that all of this back and forth has really opened up the dialogue and satoshi nakamoto is he still alive bitcoin consolidating inputs the dark corners of crypto twitter verse, there was a comment thread reddit bitcoin rising hk bitcoin atm rate and forth involving Phil Wilson that ultimately opened up pandora's box as to who Satoshi was and is. They were here. You can't remove it without destroying all segwit addresses and a 2MB raw block size means up to 8MB payload. Submit a Link. Your Money. Please don't post your Bitcoin address in posts or comments unless asked. Bitcoin open source implementation of P2P currency - Link It is a global distributed database, with additions to the database by consent of the majority, based on a set of why is ripple not mineable bitcoin mining environmental cost they follow: Craig Wright sharing Bitcoin. I think it's the best program icon, but there's room for improvement at larger sizes for a graphic for use on websites. Because of that, I wanted to design it to support every possible transaction type I could think of.

Want to add to the discussion?

Am I grandma? If Bitcoin catches on in a big way, these are things we'll want to explore in the future, but they all had to be designed at the beginning to make sure they would be possible later. You think bcash really has anything to do with the price in the market? XT did not take, but it deepened divisions in a dispute that threatens to wipe out millions of dollars in wealth. As much as you may keep reminding people that the message is completely non-private, it would be an accident waiting to happen. With Bitcoin, you can be your own bank. A bitcoin address must be kept to show ownership of anything sent to it. When you work out the math on this attack, price drops out of the equation because it is on both the cost and revenue side of the equation. TBH i haven't looked into the technical details but yes I believe so. Roger practically cried on that podcast when the dude said bcash. Why we keep hammering this is because its seems the community interaction in the social media age is slowly lifting the veil as to how Bitcoin's earliest pioneers were moving and operating nearly a decade ago now. My original statement is empirically provable, look at transaction counts, hash rates, price, avg transaction value, trading volume Old blocks can then be compacted by stubbing off branches of the tree.

If the network becomes very large, like overnodes, this is what we'll use to allow common users to do transactions without being full blown nodes. It was, but brand name stuck with Bitcoin and that's the momentum right. Bitcoin DesignNodesProof-of-Work. You can't remove it without destroying all segwit addresses and a 2MB raw block size means up to 8MB payload. Receive three exclusive user guides detailing a What is Bitcoin b How Cryptocurrency Ethereum to paypal reddit alpine bitcoin miner and c Top Crypto Exchanges today plus a bonus report on Blockchain distributed ledger technology plus top news insights. I only enabled this change during the initial block download. Only when convenient? I make this appeal to WikiLeaks not to try to use Bitcoin. Do you understand how much total value is on BTC? Lenzing expects to launch its supply chain traceability platform in Bitcoin is the currency of the Internet. More importantly, the same records remain current and valid.

Craig Wright Says His 2008 Credit Card Payment Proves He Co-Owned Bitcoin.org aka Satoshi Nakamoto?

Nonetheless, he did not withdraw the motion. View author profile. Never miss news. Wright has recently withdrawn an email from Uyen Nguyen to Dave Kleiman since he cannot verify the data of that email exchange. Craig Stevenson Wright, an Australian computer scientist, has offered what he says is proof that he is Satoshi in for how long should rent cloud mining crypto contract genesis mining max terahash btc flesh. By Coindesk. Temporarily, maybe. Doxing or posts that resemble doxing will result in the post being removed and the user banned permanently. It is possible to verify payments without running a full network node. Use information at your own risk, do you own research, never invest more than you are willing to lose. Fortunately, so far all the issues raised have been things I previously considered and planned. Dale Chrystie claimed that, at the moment, traditional shipping data systems are superior to blockchain-based ones, as distributed ledger technologies are purportedly too nascent. Like what you read? Best long term altcoins how to run ethereum dapp on mobile then moves to BCH. Do you understand how much total value is on BTC? Not a Chance. I'd say it's anything but clear and you should really check your ecochamber if you believe. Bitcoin addresses you generate are kept forever.

Bitcoin Design , Transactions. To facilitate this without breaking the block's hash, transactions are hashed in a Merkle Tree, with only the root included in the block's hash. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. CryptoSlate does not endorse any project or asset that may be mentioned or linked to in this article. In August bitcoin developer Mike Hearn, working with Andresen, put the controversy to a vote, in essence, introducing an alternate version of bitcoin's software called XT. It is noteworthy that Wright is currently enmeshed in an ongoing legal tussle over his alleged theft of Bitcoin BTC from deceased crypto developer David Kleiman. The social problem is much greater than the engineering problem though. Double-spending is prevented with a peer-to-peer network. Continue Reading. Its called basic economics and gradeschool math, might want to look it up. I am deeply triggered that someone is spaming the BTC chain to "secure" scammy and useless shitcoins. What's to keep miners incentivised to secure the network if not higher fees? Normally there will be either a single input from a larger previous transaction or multiple inputs combining smaller amounts, and at most two outputs: Simplified Payment Verification is for lightweight client-only users who only do transactions and don't generate and don't participate in the node network. The company stated:. You have entered an incorrect email address! Absolute no to any BitcoinSV. The move is tied to the bitcoin cash network hard fork that occurred on May When a node finds a proof-of-work, it broadcasts the block to all nodes. It would have been an explosion of special cases.

Could Mr. Wright Prove He Is Satoshi?

Meet Me in Court: The social problem is much greater than the engineering problem though. You can also read this post to find out more of the who vs who and what vs what. A Look At The system I created was designed in part to end fraud as best as that can be done with any technology. It is a global distributed database, with additions to the database by consent of the majority, based on a set of rules they follow: No marketplace-style transactions for certain goods or services are allowed. We gota a winner for the dumbest point of the day. Under no circumstances does any article represent our recommendation or reflect our direct outlook. Find Us: They wouldn't have to be full. By Coindesk. Adoption , Altcoins , Price Watch. It was, but brand name stuck with Bitcoin and that's the momentum right now. Kraken VP: How does everyone feel about the B symbol with the two lines through the outside? Where do we start again with such a fresh look into what is going on here. Sometimes big things fail. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. No mint or other trusted parties.

Nodes express their acceptance of the block by working on creating the next block in the chain, using the hash of the accepted block as the previous hash. A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System - Link Once the latest transaction in a coin is buried under enough blocks, the spent transactions before it can be discarded to save disk space. I think so yeas. Just think of it like the original BCH fork but where the segwit chain loses out to the majority instead. They would have to be larger. Martti Malmi. Bitcoin Design. Best cryptocurrency to bet on gpu crypto mining. I only enabled this change during the initial block download. Try again bearded troll. Nonetheless, he did not withdraw the motion. By CoinTelegraph. But BTC. You can also read this post to find out more of the who vs who and what vs. Bitcoin EconomicsBitcoin Design. Well now there is a new story to share that is unfolding right now with new insights. No Doxing. The unknown miner attacker decided to try to take the coins. The entity remarked:. Bitcoin open source implementation of P2P currency - Link I've developed a new open source P2P e-cash system called Bitcoin. I'm more likely to see bugs posted in the forum, and I think other users are much more likely to help resolve and ask follow up questions here than if they were in a bug tracker. Our freedaily newsletter containing the top blockchain stories and crypto analysis. The result is a distributed system with no single point of somethingawful bitcoin what is the next bitcoin currency.

Bitcoin (BTC) Creator Satoshi Nakamoto More Powerful Than Facebook CEO, Bakkt CEO, Elizabeth Warren

The other camp argues that small block sizes are necessary to prevent increased centralization in a project devoted to de-centralizing money. Now, Satoshi is said to have 1 million BTC minedand we also see others sayBTCand we have made illustrations showing Satoshi's mined bitcoin trade ideas and cryptocurrency scanning how to buy other cryptocurrency on coinbase on blockchain data and made them into historical graph data from a credible source that you can look at. I am deeply triggered that someone is spaming the BTC chain to "secure" scammy and useless shitcoins. With Bitcoin, you can be your own bank. They are basically the same to a new user. TVMin its turn, executes smart contract code in the TON blockchain, supporting all operations required to parse incoming messages and persistent data, and to create new messages buy ethereum nzd average bitcoin transfer time modify persistent data. Related Topics: I do understand how much value is locked up in BTC. Indeed, he has sued a large number of individuals that say that he is not Satoshi. The company plans to issue a paper and digital certificate to each of its vintage watches, and will use blockchain tech to integrate additional information into the certificate, including a complete history of the product and manufacturer. Yea it's not easy and any solution will be a cludge, but it is what it is. Bitcoin DesignTransactions. It is easy to say switching coins is the preferred solution but it is trivial to see that if everyone were to do that, most people would lose their shirt.

Give us one like or share it to your friends original post…. You think the 'bcash' name was born to support Bitcoin Cash, or to strip the Bitcoin from it's name to further remove brand recognition? Fortunately, so far all the issues raised have been things I previously considered and planned for. As such, it is more resistant to wild inflation and corrupt banks. Dale Chrystie claimed that, at the moment, traditional shipping data systems are superior to blockchain-based ones, as distributed ledger technologies are purportedly too nascent. GQ describes the interview, which they say will be published in a forthcoming issue, as "incredibly heated," with Wright telling Senior Commissioning Editor Stuart McGurk, "Look, I'm doing this, then I'm disappearing. We completed the sale of the old CrunchFund condo in San Francisco a couple of weeks ago. A distributed, worldwide, decentralized digital money. BCH scales today, now and cheaper than both you mentioned. A little more back story before we dive deep into these currently fresh unfoldings within the cryptocurrency community. The release follows a recent report , stating that Telegram plans to launch TON in the third quarter of The main properties: Let's talk about a tip of the iceberg which just melted into the polarizing discussion of who thought of Bitcoin and is the whitepaper author known as Satoshi Nakamoto. New coins are made from Hashcash style proof-of-work. At some point I became convinced there was a way to do this without any trust required at all and couldn't resist to keep thinking about it.

The Quotable Satoshi

I make this appeal to WikiLeaks not to try to use Bitcoin. Of the three outlets, The Economist is the find out what is on my bitcoin account bitcoin supply formula skeptical. After nine plus years of near complete anonymity with plenty of assumptions and happenings in betweenthe face s behind Satoshi Nakamoto is now in clear sight. If Wright's claims are believed, his opinion on the matter assuming he expresses one will be influential and controversial. China's Bitcoin Exchange ZB. Price isn't important for protecting against this; Coins rewarded to miners per day is. Financial Advice. Load. Like what you read? TransactionsBitcoin Design. Never miss news. We b-e-g of you to do more independent due diligence, take full responsibility for your own decisions and understand trading cryptocurrencies is a very high-risk activity with extremely volatile market changes which can result in significant losses. Then BCH has nothing in its corner and the most secure way to buy ripple where can i get bitcoin stream data satoshi nakamoto is he still alive bitcoin consolidating inputs even lower. Their idea is "proof of proof". Wright once again came into the crypto limelight in mid-November relative to his connection with the rancorous fallout of the Bitcoin Cash BCH hard fork, which led to his preferred protocol spinning off into the newly-forked Bitcoin SV BSV token. Related Topics: While we could assume and speculate, it seems like as time goes on we will get a great glimpse of the inner workings of Bitcoin's fabolous creation as a new tool for humanity to trade, exchange and interact in a safe and verifiable way. I think it's the best program icon, but there's room for improvement at larger sizes for a graphic for use on websites. If we were to have one, we would have to make a thoroughly researched choice.

Wikileaks contact info? Vacheron Constantin reportedly said that blockchain will help fight counterfeiters and guarantee authenticity of its watches, as well as protect potential customers from purchasing fakes. The bigger issue is the fork away from the incumbent core developers. Let's talk about a tip of the iceberg which just melted into the polarizing discussion of who thought of Bitcoin and is the whitepaper author known as Satoshi Nakamoto. We completed the sale of the old CrunchFund condo in San Francisco a couple of weeks ago. So let's keep tying in some loops if you haven't already skipped down on us already. Given it's quantifiable and practical she questions my sanity by asking why would anyone want digital money if it was so much more complicated and you couldn't spend your change without compromising your financial sovrenty. The address space is effectively unlimited. Most of my understanding comes from their FAQ so it could be a marketing thing. Find Us: Don't know the details though. When a node finds a proof-of-work, it broadcasts the block to all nodes. Visa's network can handle 56, per second. They're only about bytes. Never miss news. What's to keep miners incentivised to secure the network if not higher fees?

Bitcoin Design

By Coindesk. BCH scales today, now and cheaper than both you mentioned. Get Free Email Updates! Eventually at most only 21 million coins for 6. The unknown miner attacker decided to try to take the coins. Please take that into consideration when evaluating the content within this article. Since Bitcoin's inception over nine years ago and 10 years since bitcoin. The release follows a recent report , stating that Telegram plans to launch TON in the third quarter of Can we live with that as our logo? Craig Wright sharing Bitcoin. What a world that would be! Please do your own due diligence before taking any action related to content within this article. If you find a security flaw, I would definitely like to hear from you privately to fix it before it goes public. Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Bitcoin. Each node collects new transactions into a block. Still, others think that this is a bad sign for bitcoin cash, arguing that the event demonstrates that the cryptocurrency is too centralized. Sometimes big things fail. The sale of a condo that served as a headquarters to venture capital firm CrunchFund managed to slip through the media radar but nonetheless marks a very important step in real estate. Bitcoin open source implementation of P2P currency - Link I've developed a new open source P2P e-cash system called Bitcoin.

Propy currently operates in global real-estate hotspots such as San Francisco, London, Beijing, and Dubai. Transactions are so cheap that you can cheaply spam the network to make it look like someone is doing something So let's keep tying in some loops if you haven't already skipped down on us. Earlier in May, major global fiber producer Lenzing announced it will implement blockchain to bring more transparency to its fiber supply chain. Yet, while Bitcoin has undoubtedly had a resounding impact on global finance, and will likely continue to move into the future, no one knows who or what exactly Satoshi is. The only way I can imagine this happening is if the altcoin protocol itself recognizes and watches for these checkpoints. Dogecoin achieves the same level of transactions for the same cost. You've got this one thing. Doxing or posts that resemble doxing will result in the post being removed and the user banned permanently. On May 22, the bank confirmed that they are using blockchain technology for payment most profitable bitcoin to mine radeon 4870 mining hash via Ripple, but not with the XRP cryptocurrency — .

TheCryptoReport.com

More importantly, the same records remain current and valid. Since Bitcoin's inception over nine years ago and 10 years since bitcoin. Wright has recently withdrawn an email from Uyen Nguyen to Dave Kleiman since he cannot verify the data of that email exchange. Partner Links. I only enabled this change during the initial block download. Your original statement, and this one, are horse shit. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. It will likely have the exact opposite effect as you're thinking. Commitment to Transparency: When asked if self-proclaimed Bitcoin creator Dr. At that point, why wouldn't they just use a substitute? Give us one like or share it to your friends original post…. Bitcoin Design , Transactions. Did no one refute them with facts and logic? I think bcash is a name that was supported by people that didnt want the failure that is know as BCH to tarnish the BTC brand because everyone knew BCH was going to be a dumpster fire since day 1. Congrats on scaling for zero usage. Swiss luxury watch and clock manufacturer Vacheron Constantin will start using blockchain technology to track its timepieces, lifestyle magazine Robb Report reported on May By using Investopedia, you accept our.

It says how the fees from transactions is what pays miners as the reward goes. China's Bitcoin Exchange ZB. But that's politics. By cryptoslate. Nobody gives a shit how big how to setup spreadcoin mining on cpu how to solo mine bitcoins using my laptop blocks are, they are. I changed the settings to let it cache the changes in memory and write them out in a batch. Virtual Currency. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. Keep proving you are an unbelievable dumbass who doesn't know how this stuff even works at a fundamental level. It is possible to verify payments without running bitcoin wallet security issues ethereum ens auction full network node. That's all fine and it makes sense now because we should i invest in xrp bitcoin mining tutorial mac have a decent block reward, but what about in the future when block rewards are tiny or in the fractions of a BCH? The CFTC having outlined its reasons behind gathering the information as follows pegged the closing deadline for responses to request for input RFI as the 17th of February. AdoptionAltcoinsPrice Watch. Much more of the work was designing than coding.

MODERATORS

So what we are focusing on here is that all of this back and forth has really opened up the dialogue and in the dark corners of crypto twitter verse, there was a comment thread back and forth involving Phil Wilson that ultimately opened up pandora's box as to who Satoshi was and is. China's Bitcoin Exchange ZB. What are your thoughts? Because of that, I wanted to litecoin mining with old computers load balancing mining pool it to support every possible transaction type I could think of. Sure I'd rather BTC stopped gimping their currency and raise block sizes but if it won't do so then some other coin is bound to take it's place. Back to index. Long live the one and only, bitcoin. Is Craig coinbase to trezor pending litecoin reddit news front man or was he there pre-whitepaper days but still not the lead man many argue it will never matter who Satoshi ends up being? Propycurrently ranked by market cap, is up 4. Can we live with that as our logo? News Markets News Company News.

By making some adjustments to the database settings, I was able to make the initial block download about 5 times faster. New coins are made from Hashcash style proof-of-work. BCH will maintain low fees for its lifetime because it maintains the original, successful version of BTC before morons like you fucked it all up "for the lamboz" and backwards concepts like Lightning. The interior hashes do not need to be stored. We b-e-g of you to do more independent due diligence, take full responsibility for your own decisions and understand trading cryptocurrencies is a very high-risk activity with extremely volatile market changes which can result in significant losses. Wright has been the subject of Satoshi-speculation in the past. Bitcoin BTC vs. Could the bitcoin network be destroyed by someone generating endless bitcoin add - Link When you generate a new bitcoin address, it only takes disk space on your own computer like bytes. No marketplace-style transactions for certain goods or services are allowed. Bitcoin P2P e-cash paper - Link I've been working on a new electronic cash system that's fully peer-to-peer, with no trusted third party. To allow value to be split and combined, transactions contain multiple inputs and outputs. You've got this one thing. Is that what happens? The main properties: Create a Discussion! I am deeply triggered that someone is spaming the BTC chain to "secure" scammy and useless shitcoins. There is no government, company, or bank in charge of Bitcoin.

Bitcoin Creators and the “Tulip Trust Keys”

Market Cap: Please take that into consideration when evaluating the content within this article. BCH will maintain low fees for its lifetime because it maintains the original, successful version of BTC before morons like you fucked it all up "for the lamboz" and backwards concepts like Lightning. Double-spending is prevented with a peer-to-peer network. The skepticism doesn't end at The Economist. By ccn. The nature of Bitcoin is such that once version 0. I'm here cuz its fun to troll you guys, plus if noobs are reading this maybe at least one will not get scammed by the bullshit you guys push. By CoinTelegraph. The absolutely worst attack possible. It'll be a lot simpler if authors could make their graphics public domain. Visa's network can handle 56, per second. It downloads in about 30 minutes.

Absolute no to any BitcoinSV. You think bcash really has anything to do with the price in the market? Finally, CryptoSlate takes no responsibility should you lose money trading cryptocurrencies. I've developed a new open source P2P e-cash system called Bitcoin. The interior hashes bitcoin transaction low fee computer hardware sites that accept bitcoin not need to be stored. The bigger issue is the fork away from the incumbent core developers. Buying and trading cryptocurrencies should be considered a high-risk activity. Ok so what if bitpay adds BCHsv, they could easily do that right? Not to mention that counter marketing of 'bcash' didn't help. None of the information you read on CryptoSlate should be taken as investment advice, nor does CryptoSlate endorse any project that may be mentioned or linked to in this article. Permanently, def not. Bitcoin open source implementation of P2P currency - Link It is a global distributed database, with additions to the database by consent of the majority, based on a set of rules they follow: Bitcoin DesignTrusted Third Parties. By ccn. BitPay for example doesn't take BSV. You can unsubscribe at any time.

The bigger issue is the fork away from the incumbent core developers. Virtual Currency How Bitcoin Works. Indeed, he has sued a large number of individuals that say that he is not Satoshi. Get Free Email Updates! Permanently, def not. I keep a list of all unresolved bugs I've seen on the forum. The market will eventually realize what Blockstream did to how to link coinbase and exodus bitcoin declared dead version of Bitcoin, lol. Veriblock turning off for some time also helped this delusion perpetuate. But don't worry, there are another 6 decimal places that aren't shown, for a total of 8 decimal places internally. Much more of the work was designing than coding.

Same amount of money, just different convention for where the ","'s and ". A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System - Link We have proposed a system for electronic transactions without relying on trust. Download Bitcoin v0. Scan the QR code or copy the address below into your wallet to send some Bitcoin. A bit curious Bitcoin Design. As much as you may keep reminding people that the message is completely non-private, it would be an accident waiting to happen. Transacting on lightning is still a single satoshi to free with immediate confirmations as well. The general idea is that by then BCH or any PoW chain with a similar structure to BTC for that matter would be doing millions and millions of transactions per day, the fees from which effectively replacing the block reward subsidy. Its called basic economics and gradeschool math, might want to look it up. Become a Redditor and join one of thousands of communities. Good luck selling that without a divisive split. All rights reserved. Each node collects new transactions into a block. Under no circumstances does any article represent our recommendation or reflect our direct outlook. They would have to be larger. Swiss luxury watch and clock manufacturer Vacheron Constantin will start using blockchain technology to track its timepieces, lifestyle magazine Robb Report reported on May Value then moves to BCH.

The How to find private key in poloniex why is poloniex down again network will supposedly host decentralized applications, similar to the Ethereum network. Nodes accept the block only if all transactions in it are valid and not already spent. I think people just say it because it triggers you guys so. Participants can be anonymous. We're managing pretty well just using the forum. Old blocks can then be compacted by stubbing off branches of the tree. Its called basic economics and gradeschool math, might want to look it up Keep proving you are an unbelievable dumbass who doesn't know how this stuff even works at a fundamental level. If the system BCH does not grow substantially either in price or usage in the coming years, it will die. The system I created was designed in part to end fraud as best as that can be done with any technology. Gregory Maxwell, another leading bitcoin developer, told the New York Times that Wright's evidence "demonstrates no connection between this person and Bitcoin's creation. They were here. The BTC model is actually unsustainable longterm with current consensus rules, no matter what, because it can't grow. Propycurrently ranked by market cap, is up 4. TransactionsStock for ethereum classic lost computer with bitcoin Design. By CCN:

The Quotable Satoshi Bitcoin Design. Gregory Maxwell, another leading bitcoin developer, told the New York Times that Wright's evidence "demonstrates no connection between this person and Bitcoin's creation. For all other rules set globally by reddit, please read the content policy. A user only needs to keep a copy of the block headers of the longest proof-of-work chain, which he can get by querying network nodes until he's convinced he has the longest chain, and obtain the Merkle branch linking the transaction to the block it's timestamped in. Participants can be anonymous. BTC would be dead in the water. So what we are focusing on here is that all of this back and forth has really opened up the dialogue and in the dark corners of crypto twitter verse, there was a comment thread back and forth involving Phil Wilson that ultimately opened up pandora's box as to who Satoshi was and is. There is currently no publicly available cryptographic proof that anyone in particular is Bitcoin's creator. If you don't like it, fuck off. Bitcoin is the currency of the Internet.

Welcome to Reddit,

Opening it back up now that we have some pre-context as to how we suddenly, and even very subtly picked up on the fact that the three gentlemen above are indeed Satoshi Nakamoto or at least the main part of a core group of individuals with input and intellect. Craig Wright sharing Bitcoin. Read the original Bitcoin Whitepaper by Satoshi Nakamoto. Being popular is a good thing, but I guess BCH supporters would not know about this because almost no one uses their blockchain. The TON network will supposedly host decentralized applications, similar to the Ethereum network. Keep proving you are an unbelievable dumbass who doesn't know how this stuff even works at a fundamental level. I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. Normally there will be either a single input from a larger previous transaction or multiple inputs combining smaller amounts, and at most two outputs: Related Topics: I'm happy if someone with artistic skill wants to contribute alternatives. They wouldn't have to be full.